| Team | Record | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Belmont (199) | 20-11 | -0.2370 |
| Lipscomb (206) | 21-11 | -0.3044 |
| Gardner-Webb (214) | 17-12 | -0.3499 |
| Florida Atlantic (264) | 15-13 | -0.6857 |
| East Tennessee St (286) | 15-13 | -0.7745 |
| Kennesaw St (296) | 11-15 | -0.9194 |
| Stetson (298) | 14-18 | -0.9829 |
| Campbell (311) | 10-18 | -1.2396 |
| Mercer (324) | 9-19 | -1.5184 |
| North Florida (331) | 4-22 | -1.9993 |
| Jacksonville FL (333) | 1-26 | -2.3542 |